Pete McCarthy, Part 2: ATF Undercover With the Bandidos, the Aryan Brotherhood and Operation Gideon
In the second part of his conversation, retired ATF special agent Pete McCarthy picks up after Miami, when he moved to the Southwest border. He calls firearms trafficking into Mexico a very lucrative business. He stayed in ATF's enhanced undercover program and says he never tried to be the toughest guy in the room or to oversell himself.
He explains Operation Gideon, which sent teams of undercover agents to cities with high violent crime for four-month details, starting with a test case in Phoenix. Days ran 20 hours. He also infiltrated the Bandidos in Texas and New Mexico as a prospect and the sergeant at arms of the Roswell chapter, until an informant handed him a letter laying out the whole operation. He says the leak came from someone in law enforcement, and the case was shut down.
In a case worked with the FBI, he lived with an informant who had been locked up about 16 years and went into prisons in New Mexico, Texas and Colorado under his undercover name. He says he was voted in as a made member of the Aryan Brotherhood, later given the rank of captain, and that the case solved a bunch of murders.
His last long-term undercover case was a tattoo shop in Las Vegas that targeted the 28th Street gang. A call from his daughter told him it was time to stop. He became a supervisor, ran the Albuquerque Gideon, and talks about leading by example and putting family first.
Listen or watch: YouTube · Spotify · Apple Podcasts
In his own words
"I didn't try to force the flow"
- Pete McCarthy, 7:38 (on working undercover)
"one of the biggest disappointments I ever had in my career honestly"
- Pete McCarthy, 23:59 (on the leak that ended the Bandidos case)
"I can't even help my own daughter"
- Pete McCarthy, 47:37 (on the call that ended his undercover work)
"you lead by example you know that means you eat last"
- Pete McCarthy, 54:12 (advice for supervisors)
"I was blessed I had a blessed career"
- Pete McCarthy, 1:07:50 (on his years with ATF)
Chapters
- 0:00 From Miami to the Southwest border
- 2:56 Firearms and narcotics trafficking
- 4:30 Why guns flow south
- 5:43 The enhanced undercover program
- 6:20 Fitting the role
- 8:13 An unassuming undercover agent
- 9:06 How Operation Gideon started
- 9:48 The Phoenix test case
- 10:33 Planning a Gideon
- 13:20 Four-month details and 20-hour days
- 16:01 No one leaves until the report is written
- 18:46 Infiltrating the Bandidos
- 20:00 A new life under a new name
- 21:10 The letter at Red River
- 23:22 Burned by a leak
- 25:23 The Aryan Brotherhood case
- 25:51 Two deputies in a mountain town
- 28:28 The informant who would not approve killing a cop
- 32:09 Living with the informant
- 34:26 The first night
- 35:45 One of the most violent groups he worked
- 38:03 Into the prisons undercover
- 40:05 Voted in, then made captain
- 41:18 A certificate instead of the tattoo
- 42:32 The Las Vegas tattoo shop
- 44:07 Three home invasion crews
- 46:31 Burned out
- 47:12 The call that ended his undercover work
- 51:48 Becoming a supervisor
- 54:12 Advice for supervisors
- 59:26 The Albuquerque Gideon
- 1:02:00 A homicide solved in about an hour and a half
- 1:06:13 Credit to the prosecutors
- 1:08:04 Why ATF gets a bad reputation
- 1:11:54 Closing
Chapter times are approximate.
Frequently asked questions
Did Pete McCarthy go undercover in the Aryan Brotherhood?
Yes. On a case he worked with the FBI, he lived with an informant who had been in prison about 16 years and went into prisons in New Mexico, Texas and Colorado under his undercover name. He says he was voted in as a made member, given the rank of sergeant and a few months later the rank of captain.
What was ATF's Operation Gideon?
He describes it as a program that sent teams of undercover agents, informants, technicians and tactical teams to cities with high violent crime for four-month details, working with the local police on their most violent targets. The first one was a test case in Phoenix. He later ran the one in Albuquerque as a supervisor.
What happened to Pete McCarthy's Bandidos case?
He became a prospect and the sergeant at arms of the Bandidos chapter in Roswell. During a national run in Red River, his informant handed him a letter that laid out the undercover operation. He says the leak came from someone in law enforcement, and the case was shut down for the safety of the informant and the undercover.
Why did Pete McCarthy stop working undercover?
He says he was burned out and his family was hanging by a thread. During the Las Vegas tattoo shop case, his daughter called him crying after a friend died of cancer, and he could not be there for her. He finished the trial and then became a supervisor.
How do guns get trafficked from the U.S. into Mexico?
He says a gun bought at a gun show in a border city for a few hundred dollars can be worth five or six times that in Mexico, which makes it a very lucrative business. He describes young people, even high school kids, smuggling guns across the border for money.
More on law enforcement and first responders



